DependencyGraph.java revision 80d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0
180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye/*
280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * Copyright (C) 2011 The Android Open Source Project
380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *
480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * Licensed under the Eclipse Public License, Version 1.0 (the "License");
580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * You may obtain a copy of the License at
780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *
880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *      http://www.eclipse.org/org/documents/epl-v10.php
980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *
1080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
1180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
1280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
1380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
1480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * limitations under the License.
1580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye */
1680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyepackage com.android.ide.common.layout.relative;
1780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
1880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport static com.android.ide.common.layout.LayoutConstants.ANDROID_URI;
1980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport static com.android.ide.common.layout.LayoutConstants.ATTR_ID;
2080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport static com.android.ide.common.layout.LayoutConstants.ATTR_LAYOUT_PREFIX;
2180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport static com.android.ide.common.layout.LayoutConstants.VALUE_TRUE;
2280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
2380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport com.android.ide.common.api.IDragElement;
2480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport com.android.ide.common.api.INode;
2580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport com.android.ide.common.api.IDragElement.IDragAttribute;
2680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport com.android.ide.common.api.INode.IAttribute;
2780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport com.android.ide.common.layout.BaseLayoutRule;
2880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
2980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.ArrayList;
3080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.Collection;
3180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.HashMap;
3280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.HashSet;
3380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.List;
3480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.Map;
3580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeimport java.util.Set;
3680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
3780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye/**
3880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * Data structure about relative layout relationships which makes it possible to:
3980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * <ul>
4080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * <li> Quickly determine not just the dependencies on other nodes, but which nodes
4180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *    depend on this node such that they can be visualized for the selection
4280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * <li> Determine if there are cyclic dependencies, and whether a potential move
4380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *    would result in a cycle
4480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * <li> Determine the "depth" of a given node (in terms of how many connections it
4580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *     is away from a parent edge) such that we can prioritize connections which
4680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye *     minimizes the depth
4780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye * </ul>
4880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye */
4980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbyeclass DependencyGraph {
5080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /** Format to chain include cycles in: a=>b=>c=>d etc */
5180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    static final String CHAIN_FORMAT = "%1$s=>%2$s"; //$NON-NLS-1$
5280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
5380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /** Format to chain constraint dependencies: button 1 above button2 etc */
5480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    private static final String DEPENDENCY_FORMAT = "%1$s %2$s %3$s"; //$NON-NLS-1$
5580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
5680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    private final Map<String, ViewData> mIdToView = new HashMap<String, ViewData>();
5780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    private final Map<INode, ViewData> mNodeToView = new HashMap<INode, ViewData>();
5880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
5980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /** Constructs a new {@link DependencyGraph} for the given relative layout */
6080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    DependencyGraph(INode layout) {
6180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        INode[] nodes = layout.getChildren();
6280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
6380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // Parent view:
6480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        String parentId = layout.getStringAttr(ANDROID_URI, ATTR_ID);
6580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        if (parentId != null) {
6680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            parentId = BaseLayoutRule.stripIdPrefix(parentId);
6780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        } else {
6880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            parentId = "RelativeLayout"; // For display purposes; we never reference
6980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            // the parent id from a constraint, only via parent-relative params
7080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            // like centerInParent
7180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
7280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        ViewData parentView = new ViewData(layout, parentId);
7380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        mNodeToView.put(layout, parentView);
7480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        if (parentId != null) {
7580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            mIdToView.put(parentId, parentView);
7680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
7780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
7880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (INode child : nodes) {
7980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            String id = child.getStringAttr(ANDROID_URI, ATTR_ID);
8080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (id != null) {
8180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                id = BaseLayoutRule.stripIdPrefix(id);
8280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
8380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            ViewData view = new ViewData(child, id);
8480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            mNodeToView.put(child, view);
8580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (id != null) {
8680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                mIdToView.put(id, view);
8780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
8880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
8980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
9080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (ViewData view : mNodeToView.values()) {
9180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            for (IAttribute attribute : view.node.getLiveAttributes()) {
9280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                String name = attribute.getName();
9380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                ConstraintType type = ConstraintType.fromAttribute(name);
9480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                if (type != null) {
9580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    String value = attribute.getValue();
9680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
9780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    if (type.targetParent) {
9880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        if (value.equals(VALUE_TRUE)) {
9980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            Constraint constraint = new Constraint(type, view, parentView);
10080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            view.dependsOn.add(constraint);
10180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            parentView.dependedOnBy.add(constraint);
10280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        }
10380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    } else {
10480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        // id-based constraint.
10580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        // NOTE: The id could refer to some widget that is NOT a sibling!
10680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        String targetId = BaseLayoutRule.stripIdPrefix(value);
10780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        ViewData target = mIdToView.get(targetId);
10880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        if (target == view) {
10980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // Self-reference. RelativeLayout ignores these so it's
11080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // not an error like a deeper cycle (where RelativeLayout
11180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // will throw an exception), but we might as well warn
11280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // the user about it.
11380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // TODO: Where do we emit this error?
11480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        } else if (target != null) {
11580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            Constraint constraint = new Constraint(type, view, target);
11680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            view.dependsOn.add(constraint);
11780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            target.dependedOnBy.add(constraint);
11880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        } else {
11980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            // This is valid but we might want to warn...
12080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                            //System.out.println("Warning: no view data found for " + targetId);
12180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        }
12280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    }
12380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                }
12480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
12580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
12680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
12780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
12880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    public ViewData getView(IDragElement element) {
12980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        IDragAttribute attribute = element.getAttribute(ANDROID_URI, ATTR_ID);
13080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        if (attribute != null) {
13180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            String id = attribute.getValue();
13280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            id = BaseLayoutRule.stripIdPrefix(id);
13380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            return getView(id);
13480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
13580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
13680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return null;
13780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
13880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
13980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    public ViewData getView(String id) {
14080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return mIdToView.get(id);
14180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
14280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
14380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    public ViewData getView(INode node) {
14480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return mNodeToView.get(node);
14580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
14680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
14780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /**
14880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * Returns the set of views that depend on the given node in either the horizontal or
14980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * vertical direction
15080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     *
15180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * @param nodes the set of nodes that we want to compute the transitive dependencies
15280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     *            for
15380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * @param vertical if true, look for vertical dependencies, otherwise look for
15480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     *            horizontal dependencies
15580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * @return the set of nodes that directly or indirectly depend on the given nodes in
15680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     *         the given direction
15780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     */
15880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    public Set<INode> dependsOn(Collection<? extends INode> nodes, boolean vertical) {
15980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        List<ViewData> reachable = new ArrayList<ViewData>();
16080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
16180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // Traverse the graph of constraints and determine all nodes affected by
16280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // this node
16380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        Set<ViewData> visiting = new HashSet<ViewData>();
16480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (INode node : nodes) {
16580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            ViewData view = mNodeToView.get(node);
16680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (view != null) {
16780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                findBackwards(view, visiting, reachable, vertical, view);
16880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
16980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
17080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
17180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        Set<INode> dependents = new HashSet<INode>(reachable.size());
17280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
17380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (ViewData v : reachable) {
17480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            dependents.add(v.node);
17580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
17680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
17780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return dependents;
17880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
17980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
18080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    private void findBackwards(ViewData view,
18180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            Set<ViewData> visiting, List<ViewData> reachable,
18280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            boolean vertical, ViewData start) {
18380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        visiting.add(view);
18480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        reachable.add(view);
18580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
18680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (Constraint constraint : view.dependedOnBy) {
18780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (vertical && !constraint.type.verticalEdge) {
18880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                continue;
18980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            } else  if (!vertical && !constraint.type.horizontalEdge) {
19080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                continue;
19180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
19280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
19380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            assert constraint.to == view;
19480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            ViewData from = constraint.from;
19580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (visiting.contains(from)) {
19680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                // Cycle - what do we do to highlight this?
19780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                List<Constraint> path = getPathTo(start.node, view.node, vertical);
19880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                if (path != null) {
19980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    System.out.println(Constraint.describePath(path, null, null));
20080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                }
20180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            } else {
20280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                findBackwards(from, visiting, reachable, vertical, start);
20380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
20480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
20580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
20680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        visiting.remove(view);
20780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
20880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
20980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    public List<Constraint> getPathTo(INode from, INode to, boolean vertical) {
21080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // Traverse the graph of constraints and determine all nodes affected by
21180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // this node
21280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        Set<ViewData> visiting = new HashSet<ViewData>();
21380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        List<Constraint> path = new ArrayList<Constraint>();
21480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        ViewData view = mNodeToView.get(from);
21580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        if (view != null) {
21680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            return findForwards(view, visiting, path, vertical, to);
21780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
21880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
21980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return null;
22080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
22180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
22280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    private List<Constraint> findForwards(ViewData view, Set<ViewData> visiting,
22380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            List<Constraint> path, boolean vertical, INode target) {
22480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        visiting.add(view);
22580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
22680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        for (Constraint constraint : view.dependsOn) {
22780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (vertical && !constraint.type.verticalEdge) {
22880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                continue;
22980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            } else  if (!vertical && !constraint.type.horizontalEdge) {
23080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                continue;
23180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
23280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
23380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            try {
23480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                path.add(constraint);
23580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
23680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                if (constraint.to.node == target) {
23780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    return new ArrayList<Constraint>(path);
23880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                }
23980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
24080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                assert constraint.from == view;
24180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                ViewData to = constraint.to;
24280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                if (visiting.contains(to)) {
24380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    // CYCLE!
24480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    continue;
24580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                }
24680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
24780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                List<Constraint> chain = findForwards(to, visiting, path, vertical, target);
24880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                if (chain != null) {
24980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                    return chain;
25080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                }
25180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            } finally {
25280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                path.remove(constraint);
25380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
25480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
25580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
25680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        visiting.remove(view);
25780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
25880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        return null;
25980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
26080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
26180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /**
26280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * Info about a specific widget child of a relative layout and its constraints. This
26380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * is a node in the dependency graph.
26480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     */
26580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    static class ViewData {
26680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final INode node;
26780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final String id;
26880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final List<Constraint> dependsOn = new ArrayList<Constraint>(4);
26980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final List<Constraint> dependedOnBy = new ArrayList<Constraint>(8);
27080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
27180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        ViewData(INode node, String id) {
27280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            this.node = node;
27380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            this.id = id;
27480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
27580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
27680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
27780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    /**
27880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * Info about a specific constraint between two widgets in a relative layout. This is
27980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     * an edge in the dependency graph.
28080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye     */
28180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    static class Constraint {
28280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final ConstraintType type;
28380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final ViewData from;
28480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        public final ViewData to;
28580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
28680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // TODO: Initialize depth -- should be computed independently for top, left, etc.
28780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // We can use this in GuidelineHandler.MatchComparator to prefer matches that
28880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        // are closer to a parent edge:
28980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        //public int depth;
29080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
29180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        Constraint(ConstraintType type, ViewData from, ViewData to) {
29280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            this.type = type;
29380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            this.from = from;
29480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            this.to = to;
29580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
29680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
29780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        static String describePath(List<Constraint> path, String newName, String newId) {
29880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            String s = "";
29980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            for (int i = path.size() - 1; i >= 0; i--) {
30080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                Constraint constraint = path.get(i);
30180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                String suffix = (i == path.size() -1) ? constraint.to.id : s;
30280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                s = String.format(DEPENDENCY_FORMAT, constraint.from.id,
30380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        stripLayoutAttributePrefix(constraint.type.name), suffix);
30480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
30580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
30680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (newName != null) {
30780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                s = String.format(DEPENDENCY_FORMAT, s, stripLayoutAttributePrefix(newName),
30880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                        BaseLayoutRule.stripIdPrefix(newId));
30980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
31080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
31180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            return s;
31280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
31380d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
31480d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        private static String stripLayoutAttributePrefix(String name) {
31580d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            if (name.startsWith(ATTR_LAYOUT_PREFIX)) {
31680d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye                return name.substring(ATTR_LAYOUT_PREFIX.length());
31780d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            }
31880d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye
31980d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye            return name;
32080d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye        }
32180d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye    }
32280d9301c2e874b29889c41adb0623666cf534fa0Tor Norbye}
323